Bildtext får vara max två rader text. Hela texten ska högerjusteras om den bara ska innehålla fotobyline! Photo: B. Christensen/Azote
Fishing is more than just harvesting, time to broaden the focus
- Using Mexican small-scale fisheries as a case study, the authors compare two different ways of organizing fishing – fishing cooperatives and patron-client relationships
- Trust and reliability in interactions influence pre-harvesting choices
- Actions connected to pre-harvesting, harvesting, and post-harvesting are critical for shaping outcomes
Broadening the analytical focus beyond harvesting is necessary in order to imagine new ways of governing the commons
BEFORE, DURING AND AFTER: Fishing is often synonymous with harvesting, yet harvesting is only one aspect of fishing. Pre-harvesting and post-harvesting activities such as preparing the outing, or negotiating with authorities and actors in control of production and commercialization channels, also significantly influence the outcomes of fishing.
In a paper published in Plos One, centre researchers Emilie Lindkvist and Maja Schlüter along with colleagues from the US argue that broadening the analytical focus beyond harvesting is necessary in order to imagine new ways of governing the commons.
Benefits of broadening scope
Using Mexican small-scale fisheries as a case study, the authors compare two different ways of organizing fishing – fishing cooperatives and patron-client relationships – and their effects on the distribution of benefits from harvesting.
Our study highlights the benefits of broadening the scope of inquiry beyond a narrow policy attention on harvesting to move towards a fuller understanding of commons dilemmas.
Xavier Basurto, lead author
Through in-depth interviews with fish buyers, and by gathering data related to the provision of loans to fishers, the authors shed light on how trust and reliability in interactions influence pre-harvesting choices such as access to credit, fishing means of production, or choice of organizational structure.
Incorporating new concepts
The authors conceptualize small-scale fishing as an array of linked action situations. An action situation is defined as a situation where individuals are faced with a set of potential actions which jointly produce outcomes, and in small-scale fisheries, can be categorized as pre-harvesting, harvesting, and post-harvesting.
Lindkvist and her colleagues argue that these collective action processes do not receive sufficient attention in literature, but are in fact critical for shaping outcomes particularly in terms of benefit distribution and fisher’s well-being.
The authors conclude that conceptualizing small-scale fisheries as an array of linked action situations offers a straightforward way to move beyond powerful imaginaries of fishing as harvesting.
"The risk is otherwise that we obscure considerations of activities and decisions that take place before and after harvesting, no matter how important they are.”
The authors first investigate how fish buyers select the fishers with whom to transact, by conducting in-depth interviews with fish buyers. They then assemble two longitudinal databases related to the provision of loans, one comprising data from patron-client interactions and the other from a fishing cooperative. By building a database of repeated interactions with each fisher, the authors assess how stable groups of resource harvesters are constituted. Using two conceptual devices anchored on institutional analysis – the concepts of constitutional levels of analysis and linked action situations – the authors then encourage the analysis of common-pool resources governance beyond harvesting.
Basurto, X., Bennett, A., Lindkvist, E., Schlüter, M. 2020. Governing the commons beyond harvesting: An empirical illustration from fishing. PLoS ONE 15(4): e0231575. https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0231575
Research news | 2021-04-15
What a “safe and just” future for people and planet means
Leading social and natural scientists present an approach to define a “safe and just corridor" while addressing the limits of our planet
Research news | 2021-04-14
Exploring a sense of belonging and care
Vanessa Masterson reflects on why learning more about people’s attachment to places can bring about important change
Research news | 2021-04-12
Watch the Nobel Prize Summit science sessions
As part of the Nobel Prize Summit Our Planet, Our Future, two digital academic science sessions will be held 27-28 April. Watch them here
Research news | 2021-04-12
Six targets for a sustainable textile industry
Combining circular economy and planetary boundaries can pave the way for a sustainable transformation of the fashion industry
Research news | 2021-04-11
Uncovering the “who” and the “what” in sustainability
Centre researcher Andrea Downing on what it takes to achieve fair and just futures
Research news | 2021-04-01
Ensuring a thriving ocean economy for everyone
Webinar on the rapidly developing scientific and policy attention associated to the ocean. Watch it here